Skye Boat Song (collab)

[offthewall]

This started off as a version posted on KVR by 'Gucky'.
It was a lovely interpretation of that traditional Scottish tune, but was done with all synthesized instruments. I offered to add a 'real' whistle to give it a more natural sound. This is the prototype mix that I have made. I am sending him my whistle line for him to mix in with his own version in his own manner. It will be interesting to see what he come up with.
 
James

[kara]

Lovely scottisch folk this is 
And you're right, you need a real for this

k

[Laguna Rising]

Oh, Very well, I like it
This is much more interesting

Cheers

[folderol]

Nice job. I've also just listened to Gucky's final version with your part woven into it.

The whole piece stands together very well.

I particularly like the way the whistle takes away the rigidness that his work tends to have (something I've commented on to him a few times).

[magmavander]

Hi,

very peaceful song 
It's very well done, all fits very well together.
Cool, thanks  I enjoyed!

bye

mag

[Fred S]

I particularly like the way the whistle takes away the rigidness that his work tends to have

I don't know his work, but your definitely right here. Well done, but a little mechanical.

The whistle is lovely, James. Works exceptionally well here.